Mark D. White 
The Virtues of Captain America 
Modern-Day Lessons on Character from a World War II Superhero

The first look at the philosophy behind the Captain
America comics and movies, publishing in advance of the
movie release of Captain America: The Winter
Solider in April 2014.

In The Virtues of Captain America, philosopher and
long-time comics fan Mark D. White argues that the core principles,
compassion, and judgment exhibited by the 1940’s comic book
character Captain America remain relevant to the modern world.
Simply put, ‘Cap’ embodies many of the classical virtues that have
been important to us since the days of the ancient Greeks: honesty,
courage, loyalty, perseverance, and, perhaps most importantly,
honor. Full of entertaining examples from more than 50 years of
comic books, White offers some serious philosophical discussions of
everyone’s favorite patriot in a light-hearted and accessible
way.

* Presents serious arguments on the virtues of Captain America
while being written in a light-hearted and often humorous tone

* Introduces basic concepts in moral and political philosophy to
the general reader

* Utilizes examples from 50 years of comics featuring Captain
America, the Avengers, and other Marvel superheroes

* Affirms the value of ‘old-fashioned’ virtues for the modern
world without indulging in nostalgia for times long passed

* Reveals the importance of the sound principles that America was
founded upon

* Publishing in advance of Captain America: The Winter
Soldier out in April 2014.

Table of Content

Introduction vii

Acknowledgments xiii

Notes on Source Material xiv

About the Author xvi

1 Superhuman Ethics Class 1

Utilitarianism 2

Deontology 6

A Civil War … of Ethics! 10

Virtue Ethics 13

Virtuous Deontology … No, Deontological Virtue …
Maybe ‘Deontovirtue’? 18

2 Captain America as a Moral Exemplar 25

Can a Fictional Character Be a Moral Exemplar? 26

Aren’t Fictional Characters Liable to Be Perfect? 29

Fifty Years, Dozens of Writers … One Captain America?
34

3 Five Basic Virtues 45

Courage 46

Humility 50

Righteous Indignation 54

Sacrifice and Responsibility 58

Perseverance 63

4 Honor and Integrity 76

The Honor of Captain America 76

External Honor as Respect 78

Internal Honor as Integrity 85

Principle and Compromise 88

Duty and Sacrifice (Again) 96

5 Judgment 109

Making the Hard Decisions 110

Whose Right Answer? 115

Tragic Dilemmas and How to Avoid Them 118

‘Black-and-White’ or Red, White, and Blue?

When Judgment Evolves 122

Hitting the Threshold 131

6 Principle and Politics 143

Patriotism: The Captain and America 143

Cosmopolitanism 146

The American Dream Versus the American Reality 150

‘I’m a Hero, Not a Politician!’ 153

Principle over Politics 156

Captain America in (Principled) Action 161

Secret Empire/Nomad 161

The Captain 163

Civil War 166

7 Can Captain America Help Us Achieve Greater Unity and
Civility? 178

The ‘Divided States of America, ‘ Then and Now
178

The Three Core American Ideals 181

Justice 182

Equality 184

Liberty 186

Debating What We Disagree On While Recognizing What We Share
188

Now It’s Our Turn 193

Appendix: Why Are There Seven Volumes of Captain America and
Five Volumes of Avengers? 198

References 202

Index 221

About the author

Mark D. White is Professor and Chair of the Department of Philosophy at the College of Staten Island/CUNY and co-editor of Batman and Philosophy.